Our reporting is funded by readers like you. Your support helps us deliver exclusive, agenda-setting coverage from San Francisco courts and hold the criminal justice system to account. Become a supporter.

CrimeSan Francisco

Man seized by ICE in San Francisco fabricated claims to stay in US and was “not worthy of belief,” judge found

Further details are emerging about the man whose dramatic arrest by ICE agents in SoMa on Monday triggered a protest at City Hall, including how his account of fleeing machine-gun fire in El Salvador fell apart under scrutiny from immigration judges.

Milton Ramos-Rodriguez, 51, was branded “not credible” by an immigration judge in 2013 after admitting he had given false testimony to a federal asylum officer “in order to enhance his claim,” according to a Justice Department brief filed in his failed appeal to the Ninth Circuit.

The judge ruled on October 10 2013 that the “material fabrication is sufficient for the court to conclude that [Ramos’s] subsequent statements are not worthy of belief,” the brief states.

Ramos-Rodriguez had claimed that after his deportation in 2004, Salvadoran soldiers stripped him at the airport, spotted his gang tattoos and a tattoo of Che Guevara, called him a traitor and told him he had 15 days to live.

He testified that masked police later hunted him at his home, and that when he escaped in a taxi they “sprayed” it with machine-gun fire as it drove away. The taxi, he said, took him to the Guatemalan border, and he made his way back to the US.

He had told an asylum officer that MS-13 gang members tried to kidnap him and shot at him. Under questioning in court he conceded this was untrue, saying gang members “never approached me with weapons or anything” and only “came and talked to [him] verbally.”

He initially blamed the asylum officer for “mixing…up” the questions, then said he had been “dazed out” and “drowsy” from medication. He eventually admitted he invented a second encounter with the gang “because [he] thought it [would] help” his case, the brief states.

He had also told the asylum officer he suffered no physical harm from Salvadoran police, despite later testifying they beat him with a baton. He told the court he did not think being hit with a baton amounted to physical harm.


According to the brief, Ramos-Rodriguez came to the U.S. illegally aged eight in 1983. In 1992 he pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and was sentenced to 10 years in prison. He was deported on December 20 2004 and was back in the U.S. illegally within a month.

A further arrest brought him to the attention of ICE in 2012, and he sought protection under the Convention Against Torture, an international treaty that bars sending people to countries where they are likely to be tortured.

A judge rejected his claim in March 2013. The case was sent back for a second hearing, where the same judge found him not credible and ruled he had failed to show he would be tortured if returned. Further appeals to the Board of Immigration Appeals and a bid to reopen the case failed, and the Ninth Circuit denied his petition in 2017.

ICE agents from the San Francisco field office arrested Ramos-Rodriguez on Monday morning in SoMa. A witness who watched from his apartment window said he saw plainclothes agents with guns drawn and heard the man repeatedly ask who they were, while claiming to be a US citizen.

ICE described him as a “prior deported felon” with a California voluntary manslaughter conviction and an alleged affiliation with the Sureños gang. His lawyer, Francisco Ugarte of the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office, said at Tuesday’s rally that he was working to determine his client’s immigration background and verify the allegations.


The U.S. Attorney’s Office in San Francisco declined to comment on whether it intends to charge Ramos-Rodriguez with falsely claiming to be a U.S. citizen, not least to deter other illegal aliens from endangering officers’ safety by seeking to gin up a mob during arrests. The offense, under 18 U.S.C. § 911, carries a fine, up to three years in prison, or both.

LA’s top federal prosecutor, Bill Essayli, would likely already have filed that charge. It remains to be seen whether Craig Missakian, the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of California, will.

Please sup­port our work by making a donation

To be no­ti­fied of new sto­ries fol­low us on X

Related Articles

San Francisco Public Safety News