A man convicted of first-degree murder for raping, strangling and bludgeoning to death a pregnant Oakland mom in her own home has won parole after 26 years’ imprisonment.
Ellis Lockett was prime suspect in the 1974 killing of 19-year-old Susan Murphy but remained free until 2000, when advances in forensic science allowed prosecutors to pursue the case again.
He was convicted of first degree murder by an Alameda jury in 2002.
A newly released transcript of his October 6 parole hearing shows Lockett told the panel he had spent the day of the killing cruising downtown Oakland in an unsuccessful search for prostitutes, before going to his niece’s house and seeing his victim pulling up at her home across the street.
“When I seen her I decided I was just going to rape her,” explained Lockett to parole commissioners.
“I forced my way into her home, told her that I was going to fuck her. And coerced and threatened her to take off her pants, and I raped her,” he added.
After the attack he panicked, he said. “I thought I was going to get caught so the only thing I could think of to try to get out of the situation was to keep her silent. And the only way I could do that was, I think, I started strangling her. And then I see a weapon, something leaning against the wall. And I picked it up and I started hitting her with it.”
He told the hearing had previously forced a 14-year-old girl to give him oral sex. He also admitted, engaging in “sexual[ly] deviant behavior” while serving in Vietnam but denied raping anyone while serving overseas.
Lockett was previously granted parole in 2021, only to see that decision promptly reversed by Governor Gavin Newsom.
Alameda prosecutors expressed misgivings about Lockett’s bid for release.
“Mr Lockett committed his commitment offense in 1974 but was not arrested until the year 2000,” said assistant district attorney April Smith, “meaning he remained free in the community for almost 25 years after committing a brutal and cruel rape, torture and murder of Susan Murphy.”
Smith said it would hardly be surprising if Lockett had committed other sex crimes, either unreported or unsolved, before he was convicted of the murder.
The panel heard from four of the victim’s relatives.
“I continue to be re-victimized through repeated parole hearings,” said Susan’s daughter Sahlima Scott. “Each hearing forces me to revisit the most painful experience of my life and confront the person responsible for destroying my family.”
“He has never been held accountable through a conviction for the rape. For more than 40 years he denied responsibility before ultimately admitting the truth. From my perspective as the surviving daughter of the victim, that history raises serious questions about accountability, honesty and genuine remorse.”
“She was only 19 years old when she was brutally and maliciously raped and murdered on her birthday,” said Susan’s brother Rick Murphy, in a statement read to the hearing.
“She was three months pregnant and she had a little girl who was six days from her second birthday who depended on her.”
“He didn’t just take her life, he violated her, strangled her and beat her so severely that she couldn’t survive, all to make sure that she could never speak his name.”
“My sister deserved to live,” said brother Michael Murphy. “Her unborn child deserved a chance to live. Her daughter deserved to grow up with her mother. Our family deserved decades more memories with the person we loved.”
“Because of the law in 1974, the judge could not sentence inmate Lockett to the death penalty or life without parole,” said Susan’s sister Margaret Smith, “so we gave him life with parole.”
“But just because he is allowed to have these hearings, it does not mean he should be released into society. He is a sick human being who has a history of preying upon young girls and women.”
“Myself and my entire family are pleading with you to please not consider releasing inmate Lockett out of prison. He walked free for 26 years. Who knows how many young girls and women he hurt and got away with it. Do you want inmate Lockett to live on your street near your wife, daughters or granddaughters?”
Their pleas fell on deaf ears. Presiding Commissioner Excel Sharrieff and Deputy Commissioner Cristina Guerrero deliberated for 30 minutes before announcing their decision to approve parole.
Sharrieef noted that Lockett qualified for special consideration as a youth offender and elderly offender. He pointed out that prison staff assessed the 75-year-old as having a low risk of future violent offending and, he observed, he had taken appropriate prison classes and maintained a good disciplinary record while inside.
Lockett remains in San Quentin state prison awaiting a mandatory review of the parole decision by the Board of Parole Hearings’ decision review unit – which checks all grants of parole for legal and factual accuracy – that must be complete by February 3 2027.
After that check, unless Governor Newsom intervenes for a second time, Lockett will be released.
Please support our work by making a donation
To be notified of new stories follow us on X





